Review Methodology

At TheRoundup, we take pride in personally testing sustainable products to help you make informed decisions about what you buy. Our review methodology explains how we review each product, and our commitment to putting our readers first and providing the best possible service.

Our 5 Key Commitments

1

YOUR INTERESTS COME FIRST

At TheRoundup, we prioritize the things that are important to you. Our reviews provide unbiased and accurate information, so you can make informed decisions about the products you buy.

2

ACCURACY AND EXPERTISE

To keep our reviews up to date and accurate, we rely on our team of experienced writers and environmental experts who give an in-depth analysis of each product. We work hard to maintain high standards of quality throughout all our content.

3

TRANSPARENCY

We believe that transparency is essential for building trust with our readers. That's why we disclose our review methodology, so you can see exactly how we evaluate the products we review.

4

PERSONAL TESTING

Before publishing a review, we spend between two and siz months personally researching and testing each product in real life scenarios, using the criteria outlined below. Our tests are always done in real homes, never in labs.

5

UP TO DATE INFORMATION

As products change and new innovations emerge, we continuously update our reviews to ensure that our readers have access to cutting-edge information about the latest environmentally friendly products.

Review Criteria

At TheRoundup, our reviews and recommendations are based on a mixture of extensive research, hands-on product testing, and the expertise of our team. We use the following criteria to assess every environmentally friendly product we review.

Environmental Impact

We evaluate the environmental impact of each product, including its carbon footprint, energy efficiency, and use of sustainable materials.

Product Performance

We test each product thoroughly in our own homes to evaluate its performance, including its durability, effectiveness, and ease of use.

Health & Safety

We consider the potential health effects of each product, including any risks associated with exposure to chemicals or other harmful substances.

Affordability

We take into account the cost of each product and assess whether it provides good value for money over the long term, taking into account its lifespan and disposal costs.

Certifications

We verify the authenticity of trusted eco-certifications such as GOTS, GreenGuard, and OEKO-TEX, to help us determine the legitimacy of a product's environmental and safety claims.

Customer Feedback

We consider feedback and reviews from real customers to gauge how well the product performs in real-world scenarios.

Our Business Model & Editorial Independence

The Roundup is an independently-owned media brand funded primarily through reader-supported affiliate partnerships. When readers click links on our site and purchase products from our retail partners, we may earn a commission. This commission structure allows us to provide free, comprehensive content while maintaining complete editorial independence.

Our editorial team operates with full autonomy in product selection, testing, and review writing. We never accept payment for positive reviews, promotional placement, or favorable coverage. Product manufacturers and affiliate partners have no influence over our testing criteria, methodology, or conclusions. If we recommend a product, it's because our testing process determined it meets our quality and sustainability standards, not because of affiliate potential.

We maintain strict policies to ensure objectivity.

  • Editorial decisions come first: Our team selects products based on reader interest, sustainability credentials, and category relevance before evaluating affiliate partnerships.
  • Testing integrity: All products undergo the same rigorous evaluation process regardless of commission rates or affiliate availability.
  • Honest assessments: We clearly communicate both strengths and weaknesses of every product we review, even when it may impact sales.
  • Transparency: If we return a product after testing or if a reader returns a purchase, the associated commission is rescinded. We only earn when readers are satisfied.

Our mission is to help readers make informed decisions about sustainable products. We only endorse items our team has personally tested and genuinely believes will serve our readers' needs and values.

TheRoundup

We specialize in testing and reviewing eco-friendly products for a non-toxic home. With our simple, practical advice, you can start living a more sustainable and chemical-free lifestyle today.
SUBSCRIBE FOR UPDATES

All Content ©2026 TheRoundup - All Rights Reserved.

Affiliate Disclaimer: This website may contain affiliate links. To cover our costs, we may earn a commission from any sale at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. 
539 W. Commerce St #2943, Dallas, TX 75208 | +1-830-904-0838 | [email protected]
Win a Sweet Zzz Honey Hybrid Mattress (Worth up to $2,599!)
heartcartchart-barsearththumbs-upcheckmark-circle