What Is a Mattress Pad? (Compared to Toppers & Protectors)

TheRoundup is reader supported. We may earn a small commission when you make a purchase via links on this site, at no cost to you.
James Miller
By 
James is an environmentalist, sustainability expert and senior editor at TheRoundup, specializing in testing non-toxic, organic and eco-friendly products. James, his wife and two daughters believe in chemical-free and zero-waste living. They aim to leave the planet in a better state than we found it, for future generations to enjoy.
James Miller
Updated: January 9, 2024

If you're looking for a simple way to make your existing mattress softer or to protect it from stains and spills, then you want either a mattress pad, a mattress protector, or a mattress topper.

But this is where many people get confused, All these products sit on top of your mattress, but the fact is they all do very different jobs. And it doesn't help that many people (and even some sleep brands) use the terms interchangeably.

But if you make the wrong choice, you could end up wasting money on a product that doesn't do the job you intended.

So what is a mattress pad? How are they different from mattress toppers and protectors, and which (if any) do you need?

In this guide, I'll answer all your questions and help you decide which solution is best for you.

What are Mattress Pads?

Definition

A mattress pad is a thin layer of material (usually less than 2") that sits on top of your mattress.

What it Does

There are three main functions of a mattress pad:

  1. Comfort Enhancement: By adding a layer of softness or firmness, tailored to your preference, you can make your mattress feel just right
  2. Protection: A mattress pad can offer a limited amount of protection, extending the life of your mattress by guarding against rips, stains, dust mites, and bed bugs
  3. Hygiene: By absorbing sweat and oils, a mattress pad helps your sleep sanctuary hygienic (a pad is much easier to toss in the washing machine than a mattress!)

What it Doesn't Do

The limitations of mattress pads are that they don't offer:

  • Waterproofing.
  • Protection against bacteria and dust particles.
  • The ability to completely transform the feel or firmness of your mattress.
  • Help with back pain.

Types

Not all mattress pads are created equal, and the variety available can cater to every sleeper's dream:

  • Cotton: Breathable and soft, cotton mattress pads are a go-to for a comfortable, non-irritating layer. They're easy to clean and great for hot sleepers.
  • Latex: Known for its durability and support, latex pads add a firm yet buoyant layer to your bed. They're often eco-friendly, hypoallergenic, and resist mold and dust mites.
  • Wool: Wool mattress pads are all about temperature regulation. Cool in the summer and warm in the winter, they offer a year-round solution for comfort. They're naturally resistant to mold, dust mites, and fire.
  • Down: Down mattress pads provide the ultimate softness. However, they're not the best option if you suffer from allergies. They're also usually at the pricey end of the market.
  • Memory Foam: These pads contour to your body, reducing pressure points and enhancing sleep quality. However, they're often synthetic and treated with chemical flame retardants. Memory foam can absorb body heat and might not be right for you if you sleep hot.

Mattress Pads vs Mattress Protectors vs Mattress Toppers: What's The Difference?

Have you ever found yourself mixing up mattress pads, toppers, and protectors?

You're not alone! These bedding buddies often get tangled in a web of who's who.

Mattress Pads

Mattress pads are typically thinner than toppers and focus on improving your mattress's feel while shielding it from everyday wear and tear.

They're perfect for adjusting your bed's comfort level slightly and protecting against dust and potential allergens.

  • Benefits: Enhances comfort. Provides protection. Can have specialized features like cooling.
  • Drawbacks: Not as thick or supportive as toppers. Limited in altering the firmness of a mattress.
  • Recommended Usage: Ideal when you're happy with your mattress but need a bit more comfort and protection.

Mattress Toppers

Imagine giving your mattress a luxury upgrade...that's what a mattress topper does.

Thicker and more substantial, toppers are all about transforming your bed's comfort level.

  • Benefits: Significant impact on comfort and support. A wide range of materials to suit every need.
  • Drawbacks: Can be expensive. Might require deeper fitted sheets due to added height.
  • Recommended Usage: Reach for the topper when you want a significant comfort upgrade or need to alter the firmness level of your mattress.

Mattress Protectors

Unlike a mattress topper or pad, mattress protectors are less about comfort and more about waterproofing, preservation, and hygiene.

  • Benefits: Extends the life of your mattress. Waterproof protection. Easy to clean.
  • Drawbacks: Generally doesn't improve the comfort or feel of your mattress. Can be crinkly/noisy.
  • Recommended Usage: A must-have to protect your mattress from spills, stains, and allergens. Often used in conjunction with a pad or topper.

Do I Need a Mattress Pad?

You would choose a mattress pad if you:

  • Need a little extra cushioning, but less than a mattress topper provides.
  • Want to enhance mattress comfort but don't have the budget for a mattress topper.
  • Want protection from dust mites and bed bugs, but don't need the waterproofing offered by a mattress protector.

How to Choose the Right Mattress Pad for Better Sleep

Making the right choice isn't just about grabbing the fluffiest option. Here are a few things you might want to consider.

Materials

Innovations in eco-friendly bedding have led to mattress pads, toppers, and protectors being made from materials like bamboo, eucalyptus, recycled plastics, and natural latex.

These materials offer sustainability without sacrificing comfort.

Thickness

This affects not only comfort but also how your sheets fit.

Consider how much you want to alter the feel and height of your mattress.

Size and Fit

Just like clothes, size matters.

Ensure the mattress pad fits your bed dimensions snugly to avoid midnight slippage and bunching.

Special Requirements

Your needs will vary if you have any special requirements, such as:

  • Allergy Sufferers: Opt for hypoallergenic options
  • Hot Sleepers: Prioritize cooling technologies or natural fibers that regulate temperature
  • Midnight Sippers: For accidental hot chocolate spills...a waterproof mattress protector might save the day

Compatibility

Not all options will work appropriately on all mattresses.

Consider your mattress type (memory foam, innerspring, hybrid, latex, etc.) and ensure that your pad, topper, or protector complements it.

Please get in touch if you need specific advice on which options will best suit your mattress.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a mattress pad if I already have a mattress topper?

No. If you already have a mattress topper, adding a pad is unlikely to make a significant difference. If you still can't get a good night's sleep then it's probably time to replace your topper or buy a new mattress.

Can a mattress pad improve sleep quality?

Yes. A well-chosen mattress pad can add the right cushioning and support, making your bed feel super cozy. This can lead to better sleep quality by reducing discomfort and disturbances.

How often should I replace my mattress pad?

It varies, but generally, you should consider replacing your mattress pad every three to five years. Of course, this depends on the pad's quality and how well you maintain it. Regular cleaning and checking for signs of wear can extend its life.

Can I use an electric blanket with a mattress pad, topper, or protector?

In most cases, yes, but always check the manufacturer's advice first. This article has more information on the topic that you might find helpful.

Will using a mattress pad affect my mattress warranty?

Generally, using a mattress pad won't affect your mattress warranty, as it's considered a protective measure. However, checking your mattress's warranty terms is always wise to avoid potential issues.

How do I know if a mattress pad is certified eco-friendly?

Look for certifications like GOTS, GOLS, and OEKO-TEX to ensure your new purchase meets strict environmental and health criteria.

Do mattress pads need special care or different washing instructions?

Care instructions can vary based on the material and construction of the mattress pad. Most are machine washable, but following the specific manufacturer care instructions is essential to maintain their quality and effectiveness.

The Final Word

Mattress pads are kind of a halfway point between mattress protectors and mattress toppers.

They offer some of the benefits of both, but only up to a point. That's why it's important you know the difference between protectors, pads, and toppers before you buy.

Here are the key points you need to remember:

  • If you want to significantly improve the comfort of your mattress, change its firmness, or address back pain issues, buy a mattress topper.
  • If you want to fully shield your mattress from dust, bacteria, and liquids, buy a mattress protector.

However, if you need a cheap solution that offers a little extra comfort and helps keep your mattress clean, then a mattress pad could be the answer.

Get In Touch

Have you used a memory foam topper to change the feel of an old mattress? Do you always invest in a mattress protector to protect the investment of a new mattress? Do you swear by a feather mattress pad and quilt to improve your sleep? Drop me a line and let me know

You May Also Like

James Miller
James Miller
James is an environmentalist, sustainability expert and senior editor at TheRoundup, specializing in testing non-toxic, organic and eco-friendly products. James, his wife and two daughters believe in chemical-free and zero-waste living. They aim to leave the planet in a better state than we found it, for future generations to enjoy.
TheRoundup.org - As Seen On
As Seen On Logos

TheRoundup

Your guide to a green and eco-friendly lifestyle. We offer simple, practical advice that anyone can follow. Together we can make a difference today & save tomorrow.
SUBSCRIBE FOR UPDATES

All Content ©2024 TheRoundup - All Rights Reserved.

108 E Main St Suite 3 Fredericksburg, TX 78624 | +1-830-904-0838 | [email protected]