12 Easy Ways to Make Your Old Mattress More Comfortable

TheRoundup is reader supported. We may earn a small commission when you make a purchase via links on this site, at no cost to you.
James Miller
By 
James is an environmentalist, sustainability expert and senior editor at TheRoundup, specializing in testing non-toxic, organic and eco-friendly products. James, his wife and two daughters believe in chemical-free and zero-waste living. They aim to leave the planet in a better state than we found it, for future generations to enjoy.
James Miller
Updated: December 8, 2023

If you're struggling with sleepless nights, or waking up with pain in your back or neck, the problem may be caused by your mattress.

However, buying a new organic mattress can be expensive, and disposing of anything that isn't broken is not good for the environment.

I've been studying organic sleep solutions for over a decade, and I've seen firsthand the misery that lost sleep can cause.

So how do you make your mattress more comfortable, and get better sleep without spending a fortune?

The good news is that you have several options, and most are cheaper and easier than you might expect...

Best Option: Get a Mattress Topper

fitting a mattress topper with straps

If you're looking to revitalize an old, lumpy mattress or adjust the firmness level of a new one, a mattress topper is the easiest and best way to do it.

My organic mattress topper reviews will help you find the best option for all types of sleepers.

Adding a topper can fix a bad mattress and completely transform the feel of your bed, depending on the thickness and material you choose.

  • To make a hard mattress softer, consider a quilted latex mattress topper. They provide pressure relief and reduce motion transfer. They do the same job as memory foam, but without all the nasty toxic chemicals.
  • To make a too-soft mattress feel firmer, look for Dunlop latex toppers. They offer a firmer, more responsive feel and are great for those seeking more support.
  • A topper with multiple natural wool layers has excellent cooling properties, which makes a huge difference if your mattress is too hot.
  • For an extra plush, luxurious feel, consider a natural wool, down or down-alternative topper.

When selecting a topper, consider your preferred sleeping position, the problem you're trying to solve, and any specific needs, such as cooling properties for hot sleepers.

If you need more help, see how to choose a mattress topper for a complete buyer's guide.

11 Alternative Ways to Make a Mattress More Comfortable

What can you use instead of a mattress topper?

1. Check Your Bed Frame or Box Spring

damaged bed frame with broken slats

The longevity and comfort of your mattress heavily depend on the support it receives from its base. An old, sagging, or broken bed frame or box spring can undermine the quality of even the best mattress.

Inspect your bed frame regularly for any damage or signs of wear and tear. Minor damage can be repaired, and individual broken slats can be replaced individually without the expense of replacing the entire frame.

If the damage is significant, you may need to replace it with a more supportive base. An eco-friendly solid wood bed frame with adequate slat spacing can ensure even support. This prevents mattress sagging, extends its life, and provides you with a far more comfortable sleep.

2. Adjust or Replace Your Pillows

woman asleep on pillowtop mattress

Pillows play a crucial role in aligning the neck and spine during sleep. Getting the right pillow can alleviate neck pain and enhance comfort.

Side sleepers generally benefit from a thicker, firmer pillow to fill the space between the neck and mattress, while stomach sleepers may need a soft, flat pillow to avoid neck strain.

Solid latex pillows can offer contoured support, while shredded latex, down, or down-alternative pillows provide a softer, more malleable feel.

Whichever loft and firmness you need, make sure you get a CertiPUR-US certified pillow so you know it's free from chemicals and flame retardants. Avoid memory foam, which is usually synthetic and therefore does contain chemicals.

Many organic pillow brands offer a sleep trial, so you can experiment with different types and arrangements to find what works best for you.

3. Mattress Rotation or Flipping

rotating or flipping a mattress

Regularly rotating or flipping your mattress can prevent uneven wear and extend its lifespan. For most mattresses, rotating them 180 degrees every three to six months is sufficient.

If you have a double-sided mattress, flipping it over in addition to rotating can further distribute wear evenly.

However, note that some modern mattresses (including memory foam and pillowtop varieties) are not designed to be flipped, so check the manufacturer's recommendations first.

4. Temperature Regulation: Creating a Cool Sleep Environment

cool sleep environment temperature regulation

Temperature plays a significant role in sleep quality. The ideal temperature is 65 degrees Fahrenheit (+/- 5 degrees for personal preference).

If you often find yourself too hot or cold, you should again consider a mattress pad or topper designed for temperature regulation. Cooling gel toppers can help hot sleepers. But wool toppers are better still. They can add warmth in the cold and are breathable when it's warm.

However, if you've decided to look for solutions you can use instead of a mattress topper, you could also try changing your bedding or sleepwear.

Using breathable, natural-fiber bedding can certainly help in maintaining a comfortable sleeping temperature.

Also, if you wear pajamas, try switching to a more breathable material - or removing them altogether.

5. Cleaning and Maintenance

person using vacuum to clean mattress

Keeping your mattress clean and dust-free is essential for a comfortable sleep environment. Use a washable mattress protector to shield against dust, spills, and allergens.

Vacuum the mattress regularly to remove dust and debris, and spot-clean any stains promptly to prevent them from setting in.

This not only maintains the mattress's hygiene but also helps in preserving its structural integrity.

6. Layering Blankets

blanket spread flat on bed

If you don't want to buy a mattress topper, a cheaper DIY solution is to layer blankets and/or a comforter on top of your mattress.

This won't fix severe sagging or structural degradation. But it can improve the sleep surface to an extent, especially if you're trying to make your mattress softer.

You can get some thick and luxurious organic blankets online that would be ideal for this purpose.

Spread the blankets flat directly on top of your mattress and layer as many as you need to provide adequate cushioning. Cover with a fitted sheet to hold them in place.

7. Get an Adjustable Bed

adjustable bed

For those with specific health needs or comfort preferences, an adjustable bed can be a game-changer. These beds allow you to elevate your head or feet, which can alleviate issues like snoring, acid reflux, or lower back pain.

They also enable you to find the most comfortable position for reading or watching TV in bed.

New adjustable beds are expensive. I'd only recommend this option if you have already tried all the above solutions, or if advised by a doctor.

You may be able to save money and resources by buying an adjustable frame second-hand. Kaiyo is a good place to shop for quality used furniture.

8. Switch to Ergonomic Bedding

woman sleeping on ergonomic bedding

Ergonomic bedding, designed to conform to your body, can reduce pressure points and enhance sleep quality.

Look for ergonomic pillows, mattress pads, or blankets that support your preferred sleeping position.

For instance, a body pillow can provide extra support for side sleepers, while an ergonomic knee pillow can help maintain spinal alignment for back sleepers.

9. Noise and Light Reduction

woman sleeping wearing sleep mask

If you're frequently disturbed when trying to get to sleep, it may not be your mattress that is at fault. The environment around you has a huge impact on your sleep quality.

It's a good idea to minimize noise and light in your bedroom to create a more restful atmosphere.

Consider using earplugs or a white noise machine to block out disruptive sounds. Blackout curtains or a sleep mask can be effective in eliminating unwanted light, ensuring your sleep environment is conducive to rest.

10. Seek Expert Advice from a Sleep Professional

consultation with a professional specialist

If you've tried various methods and still struggle with mattress comfort, it might be time to consult a professional. A sleep specialist can usually provide personalized recommendations based on your specific needs.

For some people, a custom-made mattress might be the best solution, especially for those with unique body types or chronic pain issues.

I'd recommend reading through some of the AASM patient guides to get some information about what to expect from your consultation.

11. Lifestyle Changes: The Holistic Approach to Sleep Comfort

senior citizens doing an exercise class

Finally, don't overlook the impact of your daily habits on sleep quality. If you do see a specialist they'll probably tell you the same thing, but you can make some of these changes now - for free.

Regular exercise can improve sleep quality and reduce stress, and this works for people of all ages. Yoga is a great way to relax before bedtime, but any exercise during the day will help.

Don't vary your bedtime if you can help it. Maintaining a consistent sleep schedule helps regulate your body's internal clock, leading to better sleep.

Avoid heavy meals, caffeine, and electronics before bedtime, as these can disrupt your sleep. A holistic approach to your lifestyle can complement the physical aspects of mattress comfort, leading to a more restful night.

You May Also Like

James Miller
James Miller
James is an environmentalist, sustainability expert and senior editor at TheRoundup, specializing in testing non-toxic, organic and eco-friendly products. James, his wife and two daughters believe in chemical-free and zero-waste living. They aim to leave the planet in a better state than we found it, for future generations to enjoy.
TheRoundup.org - As Seen On
As Seen On Logos

TheRoundup

Your guide to a sustainable lifestyle and eco-friendly products for a non-toxic home. We offer simple, practical advice that anyone can follow. Together we can make a difference today & save tomorrow.
SUBSCRIBE FOR UPDATES

All Content ©2024 TheRoundup - All Rights Reserved.

539 W. Commerce St #2943, Dallas, TX 75208 | +1-830-904-0838 | [email protected]
CLICK TO WIN TWO NEST BEDDING EASY BREATHER PILLOWS WORTH $262